|
|
Post by El Gato on Jan 25, 2015 20:16:12 GMT
We have had some tough clans and wars lately. We are trying to see how the clan feels about the choices the leadership has made about attack strategies employed during war. Please vote in the poll and feel free to comment below if you have an opinion you'd like to be heard.
|
|
|
|
Post by El Gato on Jan 25, 2015 23:08:51 GMT
No one wants to comment?
|
|
|
|
Post by BigBofa on Jan 25, 2015 23:37:22 GMT
In my opinion I think our strategy is fine. I am open to trying anything if it is determined we need to try another tactic. Having a strategy though is something I think we need to have before any war. Most of us know what going in guns blazin has cost us before in other clans. Free For All after the first 12 hours seems to create a problem for some members in different time zones. Some people are logging on during the last few hours of war and by then they have nothing left they can star on.
Mike you guys probably know better then the rest of us about all of that. It also didnt help that we had some knuckleheads go and attack whoever they wanted on several different occasions. (Glad they are gone)
P.S. Mike I hope all this purple isnt for the Baltimore Ravens!
|
|
|
|
Post by zod on Jan 26, 2015 2:53:05 GMT
We were beaten a few weeks ago by a group doing staged layered attacks each 5 or 10 group going first then higher levels cleaning up and attacking higher. It is a strategy I suggested long ago in a land far away. But it would require huge coordination. And I don't think that is what we are looking for. I suggest we keep our current strategy and spirit - doing the best we can with the 3-12 and intelligent 2nd attacks with discussion. Boot greedy sabateurs. I don't think we are at risk of being a war clan. Social clans like ours cooperate and participate. These are our greatest weapons.
|
|
|
|
Post by archangel on Jan 26, 2015 8:10:36 GMT
I suggest we keep our current strategy and spirit - doing the best we can with the 3-12 and intelligent 2nd attacks with discussion. Boot greedy sabateurs. I don't think we are at risk of being a war clan. Social clans like ours cooperate and participate. These are our greatest weapons. I fully assist Phil's opinion. I only got two suggestions: 1. Better war-base designs. Personally I am keen finding a tough war base for TH9 and TH7. Thanks to Gary, he provides great proposals. I would wish that we discuss more intensively the pros and cons of different designs for our bases. 2. Individual attack strategies. With what I attack which base? My proposal would be to use this forum as tool. For each war we generate a plain list of all opponent bases.
Everybody who got experience with the certain layout or got an idea how to beat, fills in a proposal (means not you are bind to the proposal).
Result is that we can be a bit more structured in what we are attacking and how. And we will learn from each other on this way.Best Till |
|
|
|
Post by marjan on Jan 26, 2015 21:47:27 GMT
For me its ok like it was, only one thing, in some wars the opposite is to strong. We know then from the beginning that 3 down is not enough, maybe then more down, or maybe free not after twelve hours but 10 hours.
Its not easy, good luck for you all.
All the best Marjan
|
|
marc
New Member
Posts: 1 
|
Post by marc on Jan 26, 2015 23:21:37 GMT
Hi guys, sometimes i have thougth the same as Marjan. we should study the enemy, and if their members are too strong, do a 4 down or 5 down. My suggestion is that calculate the average level of the enemy clan, more or less, and if its similar to our average, do 3down. if the difference between their average and our is more than 10 then do 4 down; more than 20 then 5 down; ... Is an exemple. I am sure that the most experimented players could improve my suggestion. See you in the game  Marc (Sorry for my english, i hope you understand what i wanted to say) |
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 27, 2015 17:53:46 GMT
Here are my two cents; ultimately I am OK with anything.
A simple plan is when a match is found we count the number of townhall 10's on top and drop down that number for our first hit. So, four 10's drop 4, five drop down 5 etc. (don't count 10's that are below other 9's) This ensures our top attacks generally have a good chance of more stars. Our second attack is clean-up, simply go after someone already hit you believe you can increase the star count. The top eight (or so) wait as long as they can to attack, this will give us an idea if they sound clean up low for 1 star or possibly hit the 10's. Obviously we are all adult and some can't wait, but as long as they are able is awesome.
This is not the absolute best plan, but others require massive scouting, wheelbarrows full of planning, and heaps of coordination. In my opinion we would then be a war clan and that just not what we are about in my opinion.
Again, just a thought, I am good with anything.
|
|
